

To give you an idea of just how popular this eyeliner is, on Amazon alone, it touts over 19,000 5-star reviews. What We Don’t Love: It requires more than one swipe to create an even, highly-pigmented line.

What We Love: The pointed tip dispenses the liquid liner out so seamlessly that it glides on smoothly with every stroke. No matter what kind of eyeliner you’re looking for - whether it be liquid, pencil, or gel - uncover the best eyeliners, ahead. Of the eyeliners that made the list, the incredibly popular Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner was the clear winner. Throughout their testing process, they were able to set aside the sub-par eyeliners to make room for the 11 best eyeliners. To narrow down our initial pool of 33 eyeliner contestants, we had a group of 18 testers analyze the eyeliners based on application, pigment, dry time, wear, and ease of removal. After all, some eyeliners lead to sharper lines, longer-lasting wear, and just plainly better results as a whole.īefore you go analyzing your own stash of eye goodies and comparing it to the top customer reviews at Sephora and Ulta, though, get this: We’ve researched and tested dozens of the top-rated eyeliners on the market to make it easier than ever to know which pen, pencil, or pot to reach for next.
BEST LIQUID EYELINER FOR MATURE EYES PROFESSIONAL
While part of the let-down can admittedly be chalked up to not being a professional makeup artist or beauty influencer (maybe one day!), another big contributor is the actual product you use. Have you ever ogled over the many, many graphic eyeliner looks that flood Instagram and TikTok, only to try to recreate it and ultimately feel disappointed AF? Don’t worry, you’re not alone.
